City of Darkness (九龍城寨) chronicles the fall and rise of prominent gangster and martial artist 陳洛軍 (“Lok”) as he goes into hiding in the Kowloon Walled City after a bitter fight with his former boss. Set in a picturesque rendition of 1980s Hong Kong, City of Darkness pays homage to what co-creator Andy Seto calls the most beautiful era of the city. The 32-issue long comic series is also an award-winning exemplar of several Hong Kong mainstream comics traditions – martial arts, fighting and jianghu (武術, 打鬥, 江湖) – in both its macho brotherhood plotline and its intricate, airbrushed art style.
Because it adheres to tradition however, it embodies both its strengths and weaknesses. On one hand, the art is gorgeous, the action sequences are swift, and its character designs are memorable and distinct. The creators even joke that they added flair to their appearances by drawing inspiration from present day Korean pop stars. On the other hand, the plot is driven almost entirely by masculine bravado with a heavy dose gangster brothers-in-arms support. As a result, the dialog often feels stiff, narration overwrought, and the characters are flattened into either good or evil. (Also content warning: many acts of violence, including some against women.)
Though City of Darkness played to one of Hong Kong’s most popular genres – the macho/fighting Oriental Heroes and Teddy Boy are still running several decades in – considerable effort and luck were still required to bring the series to print. The comic’s creators have remarked that they had to prove themselves online before publishers green-light their print run – even though City of Darkness is already a comics adaptation of a successful novel of the same name.
Luckily for its many fans, its creators are not yet done with the series and the universe that it created. Original author and co-creator Yuyi recently published a prequel to City of Darkness, dubbed 龍頭 (“Dragon Head”), and though it is a novel not a comic, he went to great lengths to make it his 10-year author anniversary project, and to have it printed and packaged so elegantly that it won gold at the 2018 Hong Kong Print Awards.
Title: City of Darkness 九龍城寨
Release date: 2010, re-released as graphic novels in 2016
Languages: Traditional Chinese (though scanlations can be found online, though with disappointing Mandarin phonetics)
Author: Yuyi 余兒, Andy Seto 司徒劍僑